Talk:New Phoenix Rising I (PHNIX)/@comment-5802968-20130401134216

Clone couldn't have been founded during this guild, because he hadn't founded it or made Couruscant City until he left SapIA when it fell, which was a while after the first P-R was formed. The only exception would be if he made Clone whilst in PHNIX and then returned to it after SapIA. When I met him, and he was the first PHNIX member I knowingly met, he was getting his things out of houses in Phoenix City after some rebellious event with Odribaoled and the guild was disbanded. The city looked deserted, and Eimac would help me get many more PHNIX members to join up with SapIA after it's fall.

And if -Exar- were to have joined PHNIX 1, then he would have needed to be a two-timer in SapIA at nearly the same time, or, perhaps, he left earlier and joined SapIA directly before or after the fall of PHNIX. I know I met Sinias Fluerto early on in SapIA, when it was called Dukes of Freedom , which was sometime in mid-fall.

Dobam and Loubli were some who were already level 90ish by the time they were in SapIA, so it adds up that they got there in PHNIX.